Writers often struggle to know whether to use which, that or who in a sentence. Colloquial usage can often blur the lines, but the following will help you decide which of these three pronouns to use, and when.
Adjective clauses
An adjective clause can be used to modify a noun in the same way that a simple adjective does:
“The dilapidated barn stood at the corner of the dusty road”
“The barn, which had seen better days, stood at the corner of the dusty road”
Both dilapidated and which had seen better days modify barn.
Restrictive and non-restrictive clauses
There are two types of adjective clause:
• A restrictive (or essential) clause is used to restrict the meaning of the noun. The following contains a restrictive clause:
“Horses that win races are worth a lot of money”
Here, the point is that winning horses are valuable. Remove that win races and the implication is that all horses are valuable.
• A non-restrictive (or nonessential) clause provides further information, but removing the clause does not change the core meaning of the sentence. Consider the following:
“The sports car, which was shiny and red, revved its engine and sped off”
It is nice to know that the sports car was shiny and red, but if this clause were removed, the sports car would still speed off into the distance.
The basic rule
By now, you probably have guessed what the basic rule is for using which and that:
• Use that for restrictive clauses, and do not separate out the clause using commas.
• Use which for non-restrictive phrases, and use commas before and after the clause.
Otherwise identical sentences have different meanings depending on the type of clause used:
“The window, which was on the right, let a few rays of sunlight into the dingy room”
“The window that was on the right let a few rays of sunshine into the dingy room”
In the first sentence, the point is that the widow let the sunlight into the room, whereas in the second sentence the implication is that there was more than one window, and only the right-hand one let the sunlight enter.
Exceptions
Although that is supposed to be used in restrictive clauses, people use which with increasing frequency, and it is becoming more accepted. Restrictive clauses that use which are still intelligible, as in the sentence below:
“Ships which carry oil are called tankers”
Here, it is clear that not all ships are tankers, only those which carry oil.
There are still certain types of sentence where that is almost exclusively used in restrictive clauses, including those where:
• It is the subject, as in:
“It was the cat that scratched me”
• The noun is already modified by a superlative, as in:
“Hockey is the most enjoyable game that I have ever played”
• The noun being modified is anything, nothing or something, as in:
“Is there something that is bothering you?
In some cases, that is omitted entirely from restrictive clauses and this is accepted usage, as the example below shows:
“The trophy he won is on display in his office”
However, in no circumstances should you use that in a non-restrictive clause; it doesn’t make sense, as the following demonstrates:
“The lion, that had roared previously, now settled down and went to sleep”
Who
In both restrictive and non-restrictive clauses, who must be used instead of which and that when the noun being modified is a person or group of persons, as in:
“The soldiers who came into the tent had recently returned from the front lines”
“John, who had just come in to the room, looked about in disgust”
However, there is debate whether or not it is acceptable to use that in restrictive clauses where the person is not named, as in:
“The boy that did this is in very serious trouble”
Stick to these rules, and least you won’t get into trouble, unlike the poor child above!